When it comes to maintaining healthy bones in women, resistance (weigh) training (yes you read that correctly) is one of the best things that you can do. Here’s the scoop on why and how weight training helps, and what the science says.
What’s the problem with bones with women?
By mid-life, many women find themselves in a perfect
storm of bone health - (1) estrogen levels decline when
menopause begins (2) estrogen helps protect women from
increased bone health (3) women can lose approximately
~20 % of bone density during the 5 years after
menopause. This increased level of bone health gives us
a higher percentage of bone health that easily leads to
fractures, especially in the hip, spine and wrist. And
fractures can be problematic with serious effects on
your mobility, your independence and even your death.
So: what can we do? And one of the best tools in our
toolbox is weight training.
How does weight training help the bones?
Think of your bones as living tissue that responds to
force. When muscles pull on bones, or when bone handles
load (as in lifting weights), they get an “exercise
signal” that triggers bone-forming cells (osteoblasts)
to lay down more bone.
Here are the key mechanisms:
• Mechanical strain. Combatting gravity is a strain–that
bones sense. Strain promotes bone formation.
• Muscle-bone coupling. If you’re stronger there will be
more force put through bones → bone health will
improve.
• Prevention of disuse and fall risk. When women lose
muscle and strength it results in increased falls and
less loading of bones. Weight training can help in
maintaining muscle, balance and coordination which can
indirectly lead to lower fractures.
• Bone markers are responsive. For example, in a cohort
of postmenopausal women with low bone mass after 3
months of weight-bearing + resistance training, bone
formation markers (P1NP) and the number of circulating
osteogenic cells increased.
What does the research say?
A current research study of 17 randomized controlled
trials (≈690 women) found that weight training
strengthened bone mineral density (BMD) in the spine,
neck and the entire hip. Another analysis of 24 trials
found that combining resistance training with jumping,
skipping with the weight was much more effective than
resistance alone, for the neck and spine. There’s also
data in younger women: in a randomized study of
premenopausal women (aged ~28–39) doing resistance
exercise over 18 months, BMD improved in the exercise
group. And from a practical/clinical trial: in
postmenopausal women without hormone replacement
therapy, 24 weeks of strength training preserved BMD at
lumbar spine and femoral neck compared to controls.
Finally, one news report summarized health data:
“Increasing bone strength by just 3% can slash
hip-fracture risk by ~46%”, so even modest gains matter.
What’s the practical takeaway for women?
Here are some doctor-approved points:
• Start before major bone loss. If you’re entering
perimenopause or early postmenopause, now is a prime
time.
• For optimal benefit: resistance (weight) training at
higher intensity (≥ 70% 1RM) and 3 times/week seemed
best in meta-analysis.
• Use multi-component training: resistance +
weight-bearing (impact) + balance work. Studies that
included jumps/impact had greater effect.
• But: everyday light activity (walking, chores) alone
isn’t enough to offset menopausal bone loss. Always
include adequate calcium, vitamin D, good nutrition, and
check for other osteoporosis risk factors (family
history, smoking, medication effects). Exercise is one
pillar, not the only one.
A bit of “real talk”
Many women shy away from strength training because of
myths: “My bones are too weak,” “I’ll bulk up,” or
“That’s for men.” Truth is: strength training for bone
health is not about bulking, it’s about maintaining
structure, mobility, independence and preventing serious
fractures later on. And yes — yes, your bones can get
stronger, or at least lose density more slowly, if you
engage actively.
As one British news piece said, “Muscles are key to osteoporosis prevention… low muscle mass is the first sign of low bone density.”
If you are not sure where to start: See a physiotherapist or qualified trainer who is knowledgeable in bone health, begin with form/technique, make RR/ progression slow, don't do major lifts until you are safe with the basics. 2 sessions/week of resistance + impact can still be beneficial.
Final word from your bone-doc
Weight lifting is not just a choice; it is an
intentional choice. Not because we are focused on
"aesthetics" or just "fitness", but because of what it
represents for your individual bones, or for future
mobility, or future independence. Consider your bones as
an investment: all the deliberate loading they receive
now will only strengthen your return later. Keep in
mind, even small improvements can bring about all the
difference; if you improve your bone strength by 3% your
risk of fracture will reduce dramatically. So lift
weights, do not fight against the resistance of weight
training, and give your skeleton something to grip. Your
future self will be grateful.